Why Auto Insurance Rates Are Surging in California
Published Date: 09/24/2024
Auto insurance costs across America have surged to record highs, and California is no exception. As drivers open their renewal notices, many are shocked to see double-digit rate increases — 20%, 30%, sometimes more.
In a recent Insurance Hour episode, host Karl Susman unpacked the reasons behind these painful premium spikes, explaining how inflation, supply chain disruptions, electric vehicles, accident trends, and legal costs are converging to create the perfect financial storm for drivers.
This is not just a short-term fluctuation. It represents a structural shift in how auto insurance works — and what it now costs to stay protected.
Inflation’s Direct Impact on Auto Insurance Costs
Inflation affects far more than groceries and gas. It directly drives auto insurance pricing because insurers must pay for everything that has become more expensive.
“Insurance policies are buying all the stuff that now costs more money because of inflation,” Susman explained. “When parts, labor, and medical care cost more, insurance has to cost more too.”
Today, every part of a claim costs more than it did just a few years ago:
- Vehicle parts are more expensive
- Repair times are longer
- Body shop labor rates have increased
- Medical treatment in injury claims costs more
Because insurers price policies based on what they expect to pay in future claims, inflation compounds through every layer of a single accident.
Supply Chain Delays That Won’t Go Away
Despite improvements since the pandemic, the auto parts supply chain is still far from normal.
“It still takes 10 to 20 days to get a lot of parts for cars,” Susman said. “Those parts used to be available in a day or two.”
These delays create cascading costs:
Repairs take longer.
Vehicles sit in body shops for weeks.
Insurers pay for extended rental cars.
Frustrated drivers file complaints and disputes.
With demand still high and supply inconsistent, parts remain expensive — and those rising costs show up directly in insurance premiums.
Electric Vehicles and the High Cost of Modern Repairs
Electric vehicles are transforming transportation, but they are also transforming insurance losses.
“Electric cars are built completely different,” Susman explained. “They use different materials, different safety zones, and different parts. It’s a totally different ballgame.”
EV repairs cost more because:
Parts are proprietary and often backordered for months.
Repairs require specially trained, higher-paid technicians.
Even minor accidents can damage expensive sensors and cameras.
A small bumper impact on a traditional car might cost hundreds of dollars. On an EV, that same impact can cost thousands once recalibration and electronic systems are involved. Insurers absorb those higher losses — and pass them along in premiums.
Riskier Driving and More Severe Accidents
The behavior of drivers themselves is another major factor.
“Since the pandemic, as drivers in general, we get an F,” Susman said. “The number of accidents has gone up dramatically.”
Both accident frequency and accident severity have increased due to:
Distracted driving
More powerful vehicles with rapid acceleration
Higher driving speeds and more aggressive habits
Accidents that once caused moderate damage are now producing catastrophic losses. When insurers must pay out more often and in larger amounts, premiums rise accordingly.
Technology, Labor Shortages, and Expensive Calibration
Modern vehicles are essentially computers on wheels, and that technology comes with steep repair costs.
“We used to hammer out a few dents and replace the bumper,” Susman said. “Now that bumper has cameras, sensors, and safety systems that must be recalibrated by trained technicians.”
Sensor recalibration alone can exceed $1,000 per system. Combined with rising technician wages and longer repair cycles, insurers face dramatically higher per-claim expenses — and rental car costs continue to climb while vehicles remain in shops.
Why Some Drivers Are Seeing 20% Rate Increases
A listener who experienced a 20% premium increase with Allstate asked why the jump was so severe.
Susman’s response was blunt:
“You can shop around, but don’t be surprised if the carrier you have now is indicative of what everyone else is charging.”
This is not an isolated company problem. Every insurer faces the same inflation, labor, technology, and claims environment. Switching companies may help in some cases, but the entire market is under pressure.
How One Accident’s Cost Has Multiplied
A single claim today can cost more than double what it did pre-inflation:
Fender replacement: $800 → $1,400
Labor (10 hours): $750 → $1,250
Rental car: $250 → $500
Sensor recalibration: $0 → $900
Total claim: $1,800 → $4,050
That kind of increase makes it impossible for insurers to hold rates steady.
The Role of Lawsuits and Legal Costs
Another major driver of premium increases is litigation. Personal injury attorney advertising is everywhere, and many more claims now involve lawyers.
“Claims that have attorneys involved cost more money,” Susman explained. “Whether it’s because of fees or larger settlements, the end result is higher claims and higher premiums.”
Attorneys often play an important role in securing fair compensation, but the overall effect on the insurance system is clear: more litigation leads to higher loss costs across the board.
A Parallel to California’s Home Insurance Crisis
Susman drew direct parallels between the auto insurance surge and California’s broader home insurance breakdown.
“When you’re in the opposite of a competitive marketplace, prices go up,” he said.
In both auto and homeowners insurance, shrinking competition, rising catastrophe risk, and regulatory delays have reduced consumer choice and driven prices higher.
What Drivers Can Do to Reduce the Impact
While consumers cannot control inflation or supply chains, they can take steps to limit the damage:
Start shopping 30–45 days before renewal.
Review coverage limits and deductibles carefully.
Bundle auto with home or renters insurance.
Ask about telematics or usage-based programs.
Maintain a clean driving record.
Ask about loyalty or longevity discounts.
Independent agents can also access both standard and surplus markets to locate additional options when coverage becomes difficult to find.
Insurance as a Business Under Regulatory Pressure
One listener asked whether California treats insurance more like a utility than a business.
Under Proposition 103, most rate increases require state approval. While this protects consumers from sudden spikes, it also limits insurers’ ability to respond quickly to rising costs. That tension is one reason some carriers have reduced their presence in the state.
The Road Ahead for Auto Insurance Rates
From inflation and supply chains to EV technology and accident severity, auto insurance is being reshaped on every front. Relief will not come quickly.
As parts availability improves and labor markets stabilize, costs may eventually level off. But in the near term, volatility is likely to continue.
Susman summed it up with humor and realism:
“Eat the hot dogs and wait — things will get better as time goes by.”
Final Takeaway
Today’s auto insurance prices reflect global economics, advanced technology, and changing driving behavior. Understanding why rates are rising doesn’t lower the bill — but it does help drivers make smarter decisions.
Whether you drive a gas-powered sedan or a new electric vehicle, your best protection in this market is preparation, comparison shopping, and staying informed.
Auto insurance may be getting more expensive, but knowledge remains free — and it’s still your strongest defense.
Author
