Auto Insurance Nightmare: How Inflation & EVs Are Crushing Your Wallet!
Published Date: 09/24/2024
🚗 The Auto Insurance Nightmare: How Inflation and Electric Vehicles Are Driving Your Premiums Through the Roof
Auto insurance costs across America have surged to record highs, and California is no exception. As drivers open their renewal notices, many are shocked to see double-digit rate increases — 20%, 30%, sometimes more.
In a recent Insurance Hour episode, host Karl Susman unpacked the reasons behind these painful premium spikes, exploring how inflation, supply chain disruptions, electric vehicles (EVs), and legal costs are converging to create the perfect financial storm for drivers.
This is more than a short-term blip — it’s a structural shift in how auto insurance works and what it costs to stay protected in the modern era.
🔍 Inflation’s Hidden Ripple Effect on Insurance
Everyone knows inflation makes groceries, gas, and rent more expensive. But few realize how directly it hits auto insurance.
“Insurance policies are buying all the stuff that now costs more money because of inflation,” Susman explained. “When parts, labor, and medical care cost more, insurance has to cost more too.”
Auto insurers base premiums on what they expect to pay out in claims. And those claims are now more expensive at every step:
- Parts cost more — everything from bumpers to sensors.
- Repairs take longer — delaying claims and extending rental car costs.
- Labor rates are higher — body shops and mechanics are charging more due to worker shortages.
- Medical costs are up — making bodily injury claims more expensive than ever.
Inflation doesn’t just raise one number — it multiplies across every part of a claim. And because insurers must anticipate future costs, the effect compounds quickly.
⚙️ The Lingering Supply Chain Shock
You’d think the COVID-era supply chain crunch would be ancient history by now. Not so.
“It still takes 10 to 20 days to get a lot of parts for cars,” Susman said. “Those parts used to be available in a day or two. We are still far beyond that timeframe.”
This ongoing delay has a domino effect:
- Repairs take longer.
- Cars sit in shops for weeks.
- Insurers pay more for rental car coverage.
- Customers grow frustrated — and sometimes file complaints or lawsuits.
And with fewer parts available, manufacturers and suppliers charge higher prices. As Susman put it, “When demand is high and supply is low, prices go up — and insurance follows.”
⚡ Electric Vehicles: Innovation Meets Expense
Electric vehicles (EVs) have revolutionized transportation — but they’re also reshaping insurance costs.
“Electric cars are built completely different,” Susman explained. “They use different materials, different safety zones, and different parts. It’s a totally different ballgame.”
Repairing EVs is significantly more complicated than traditional vehicles. For instance:
- Parts are scarce and proprietary. Most EV components must come directly from manufacturers like Tesla or Rivian, often with months-long wait times.
- Repairs require specialized labor. High-voltage systems, composite frames, and integrated sensors demand specially trained technicians — at a premium hourly rate.
- Minor accidents = major repairs. EVs pack sensors and cameras into bumpers, mirrors, and panels, meaning even small fender-benders can cost thousands to fix.
Susman noted that some Tesla owners have waited months for a replacement part — and insurers have to cover extended rental or loss-of-use costs in the meantime.
🧩 The Human Factor: Accidents Are More Frequent — and More Severe
Inflation and technology are only half the story. The other half? Us.
“Since the pandemic, as drivers in general, we get an F,” Susman said bluntly. “The number of accidents has gone up dramatically. Not a little bit — a lot.”
Insurers nationwide report that accident frequency (how often people crash) and accident severity (how bad those crashes are) have both risen sharply.
Why?
- Distracted driving — phones, screens, and in-car tech compete for attention.
- More powerful vehicles — EVs and newer cars can go 0–60 in under four seconds, amplifying the damage potential of every crash.
- Riskier driving habits — post-pandemic traffic patterns show higher speeds and more reckless behavior.
As Susman explained, “An accident that might have been small to medium is now large to catastrophic.”
Combine that with rising repair costs, and the result is a surge in claim payouts — which insurers must offset through higher premiums.
🔧 Technology and Labor: The Expensive Marriage of Modern Cars
Today’s cars are essentially computers on wheels. That’s great for safety — until it’s time to repair one.
“We used to hammer out a few dents and replace the bumper,” Susman said. “Now that bumper has cameras, LiDAR, and sensors, and it has to be calibrated by a trained technician.”
The cost of recalibrating just one modern safety system — say, adaptive cruise control — can exceed $1,000. Multiply that by several systems per vehicle, and the cost per claim skyrockets.
Labor is another pain point. Fewer skilled auto body technicians are entering the field, pushing up wages and slowing repairs. Insurers end up paying more both for the work and the rental cars drivers use while waiting.
💡 The Allstate Case Study: Why Premiums Jumped 20%
One caller to Insurance Hour complained that their Allstate premium rose 20% — without a matching pay raise to cover it.
Susman’s answer was pragmatic:
“You can shop around, but don’t be surprised if the carrier you have now is indicative of what everyone else is charging.”
In other words, the entire market is under pressure. Even if you switch carriers, the new company faces the same inflation, supply, and claims costs — meaning you’ll likely see similar prices.
For many drivers, this feels unfair. But in reality, insurance is a mirror of the economy it protects. When costs go up everywhere, insurance reflects that reality.
🧮 Behind the Numbers: The Compounding Cost Equation
Here’s how a single accident cost can multiply:
FactorBefore InflationAfter InflationIncreaseFender replacement$800$1,400+75%Labor (10 hours @ $75/hr)$750$1,250+67%Rental car (5 days)$250$500+100%Sensor recalibration$0$900—Total claim$1,800$4,050+125%
That’s a simplified example — but it illustrates why insurers must charge more to stay solvent.
💬 Legal Costs and Litigation Culture
Another listener highlighted a different issue: the explosion of personal injury attorney advertising — those ubiquitous billboards promising “Big Checks!” after an accident.
“You can’t drive down a freeway without seeing a billboard for an attorney fishing for clients,” the caller said.
Susman agreed that this “litigation culture” adds to the problem. When more claims involve lawyers, payouts are higher — not always because of fraud, but because of added legal fees and negotiation leverage.
“Claims that have attorneys involved cost more money,” he explained. “Whether it’s because the attorney is doing their job fighting for the client or because of fees, the end result is the same — higher claims, higher premiums.”
This isn’t about vilifying lawyers — they often play a crucial role in fair settlements. But the systemic effect is undeniable: more litigation equals more cost pressure on the system.
🏠 The Home Insurance Parallel
Interestingly, Susman drew connections between the auto insurance crunch and California’s larger property insurance crisis.
Homeowners are seeing similar dynamics: fewer carriers, more non-renewals, and skyrocketing premiums due to wildfire risks and outdated regulations.
“When you’re in the opposite of a competitive marketplace, prices go up,” Susman said.
This shrinking competition in both home and auto insurance means consumers have fewer options — and less bargaining power.
🧠 What You Can Do as a Consumer
While you can’t control inflation or supply chains, you can take proactive steps to minimize the hit:
- Shop smart — but early. Don’t wait until your renewal date. Start comparing quotes 30–45 days in advance.
- Review your coverages. Check your liability limits, deductibles, and optional add-ons. Sometimes trimming extras or raising deductibles can offset increases.
- Bundle policies. Many insurers offer multi-policy discounts for combining auto and home or renters insurance.
- Ask about telematics. “Pay-how-you-drive” programs track your driving behavior and can lower rates for safe drivers.
- Maintain a clean record. Accidents and tickets compound rate increases. Defensive driving courses can sometimes help.
- Stay loyal — strategically. Longtime customers may qualify for renewal or longevity discounts.
And if you’re struggling to find coverage? Independent agents (like Susman himself) can access both admitted and surplus-line markets to locate viable options.
🧩 The Systemic Question: Is Insurance Still a Business — or a Utility?
One listener from Placer County posed a provocative question:
“Isn’t California treating insurance like a utility instead of a business? If regulators dictate what insurers can charge, how can they stay viable?”
It’s a fair point — and one that resonates deeply within the industry. California’s regulatory framework under Proposition 103 requires state approval for most rate changes, limiting insurers’ ability to respond quickly to rising costs.
As Susman and other experts have argued in previous episodes, this rigidity is a core reason why many insurers have reduced their presence in the state.
🏁 The Road Ahead
From inflation and supply chains to EVs and lawsuits, the pressures on the auto insurance market are immense — but not insurmountable.
As technology advances and parts availability improves, prices may eventually stabilize. But in the near term, consumers should expect continued volatility and limited relief.
Susman’s bottom line?
“Eat the hot dogs and wait — things will get better as time goes by.”
It’s humor with a hard truth behind it: patience, planning, and proactive communication with your agent are the best tools drivers have right now.
✍️ Final Takeaway
Auto insurance today reflects a convergence of global economics, technology, and behavior. Understanding the “why” behind your higher bill doesn’t make it easier to pay — but it helps you make smarter choices moving forward.
Whether you drive a gas-powered Camry or a sleek new Tesla, your best defense in this auto insurance storm is knowledge — and perhaps, as Karl Susman jokes, a few extra hot dogs in the fridge.
Author