Keep me updated!
As California faces yet another devastating wildfire season, homeowners are grappling not just with the immediate dangers of evacuation, but with a pressing question: Will my insurance cover me when I need it most?
During a recent interview on NewsNation, insurance expert Karl Susman, himself an evacuee from the Palisades Fire, offered crucial insights into California’s complex insurance landscape amidst these disasters. The conversation delved into a key intervention by the California Department of Insurance (CDI) — a temporary ban on insurance policy cancellations and non-renewals for residents in wildfire-affected areas. While this moratorium provides some relief, Susman also highlighted the nuances and limitations that homeowners must understand in this rapidly evolving situation.
1. A Crisis on Two Fronts: Fire and Financial Exposure
The Palisades Fire has become a symbol of California's ongoing insurance crisis. As the flames ravaged neighborhoods, tens of thousands of residents were forced to evacuate, while insurers faced mounting claims. Major carriers like State Farm, Allstate, and Farmers have already pulled back from high-risk fire areas, making it more challenging for homeowners to find coverage.
Susman highlighted the tough situation homeowners face when insurers withdraw from these regions:
- Private insurance options are shrinking, leaving homeowners with two choices: find more expensive coverage or rely on the California FAIR Plan, which offers basic fire coverage but lacks the breadth of a standard policy.
- While insurance availability is becoming more difficult, Susman explained that it’s still possible to secure coverage. But navigating this crisis requires understanding how the system works and being proactive.
2. The Commissioner’s Intervention: A 12-Month Lifeline
To shield homeowners from the immediate risk of losing coverage during a fire, California Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara enacted a 12-month moratorium. This ban prohibits insurers from canceling or non-renewing policies for those in wildfire zones.
While this moratorium provides temporary relief, Susman cautioned that it does not automatically renew policies or lower premiums. It’s critical for homeowners to actively contact their insurers to reinstate policies or confirm their coverage status. This ensures homeowners aren’t caught off guard once the moratorium ends.
3. Why the Ban Matters—and Its Hidden Limits
The moratorium offers critical protection for those living in affected areas, providing homeowners with more time to recover and rebuild. However,
Susman pointed out important limitations:
- Only applies to specific ZIP codes designated by the CDI.
- Premiums may still rise after the moratorium ends.
- Doesn’t cover new construction: Rebuilding a home requires a different type of policy, such as a builder’s risk policy.
Many homeowners might unknowingly face gaps in coverage during the rebuilding process if they don’t take these nuances into account.
4. When Homeowners Become Their Own Risk Managers
Susman, who had to evacuate with his family, emphasized the importance of proactive risk management. He shared how his family took steps to reduce the risk of fire damage: clearing trees and brush from the roofline and creating defensible space around the property.
Insurance companies are now requiring wildfire mitigation measures as a condition for issuing or renewing coverage. This shift reflects the growing reality that homeowners must actively participate in reducing their fire risk if they wish to keep insurance coverage. It’s no longer just advice — it’s a requirement.
5. The Federal Factor: When Washington Steps In
President Joe Biden pledged 100% federal coverage for California’s fire response, including firefighting and disaster relief. While federal aid can assist in emergency response and debris removal, Susman stressed that federal funds cannot replace private insurance.
“You can’t rely on federal relief to rebuild your home,” Susman warned. Private insurance is critical for long-term recovery, and without it, homeowners risk facing significant financial hardship.
Keep me updated!
6. A Look Ahead: Sustainable Insurance and Market Reform
Despite the crisis, Susman expressed cautious optimism regarding California’s recent regulatory efforts. In late 2024, the California Department of Insurance introduced the Sustainable Insurance Strategy. This reform requires insurers to offer coverage across the entire state, including high-risk fire areas.
The goal is to stabilize the market by ensuring insurers provide coverage statewide, though higher rates will be expected in high-risk zones. While the reforms are promising, homeowners in fire-prone areas may face increased premiums, and it will take time before these changes result in widespread market stability.
7. Lessons for Homeowners: Staying Insured During Crisis
For homeowners navigating wildfire season and the ongoing insurance crisis, Susman offered practical advice:
- Stay in contact with your insurer or broker: Verify your policy’s status and avoid assuming it’s active.
- Keep premiums current: If you missed a payment, request reinstatement.
- Document everything: Take photos and videos of your property and belongings.
- Fireproof your home: Implement insurer-recommended mitigation measures like clearing vegetation and installing ember-resistant vents.
- Understand policy gaps: If you’re rebuilding, make sure you have a separate builder’s risk policy.
- Plan for renewal changes: Be prepared for potential rate increases after the moratorium ends.
8. The Bigger Picture: Resilience Over Reaction
Susman’s personal experience as an evacuee highlighted the importance of resilience. While it’s impossible to prevent wildfires or other natural disasters, homeowners can take steps to ensure they’re prepared.
“Everything happens for a reason,” Susman reflected. “We’re together, we’re safe, and that’s what matters. Everything else can be rebuilt.”
The broader takeaway from the interview is that insurance isn’t just about covering losses; it’s about building a foundation of preparedness and resilience. Managing risk intelligently and staying proactive are the keys to weathering the challenges of a changing world.
Conclusion: The Insurance Lifeline Amid the Flames
As California faces yet another devastating wildfire season, the insurance market is under intense pressure. While temporary moratoriums offer relief, the underlying challenges remain: securing stable coverage in fire-prone areas, dealing with rising premiums, and adapting to an evolving risk landscape.
For now, homeowners in wildfire zones can take comfort in the fact that their insurance won’t disappear overnight. But to navigate the future, they must remain vigilant, prepared, and proactive.
As Susman aptly summed up: “Challenging, but not impossible.” The future of insurance in California, and across the U.S., depends on smart reforms, individual preparedness, and a collaborative effort between homeowners, insurers, and regulators.
Keep me updated!
