California Insurance Crisis Spurs Emergency Call from Placer County
Published Date: 09/18/2024
When wildfires tear across California, the destruction is easy to see — burned hillsides, destroyed homes, and displaced families. But a second, quieter disaster is spreading alongside the flames: the steady collapse of California’s homeowners insurance market.
This time, the warning isn’t coming from insurers or regulators. It’s coming from Placer County, whose leaders have formally asked Governor Gavin Newsom to declare a state of emergency for insurance. Their message reflects a growing urgency across the state as homeowners face mass non-renewals, soaring premiums, and shrinking access to private coverage.
In a recent ABC10 segment on To The Point with Alex Bell, the scale of the crisis became clear. From suburban neighborhoods in Rocklin to rural foothill communities, even areas once considered “low risk” are now being swept into the insurance fallout.
A Crisis Reaching Even “Safe” Suburban Neighborhoods
Rose Gonzalez lives in Whitney Ranch, a master-planned community in Rocklin that rarely sees direct wildfire threats. Yet she recently received a non-renewal notice from her carrier, Kemper, citing wildfire risk as the reason.
Her premium jumped from $1,600 to $1,900 after moving to a new insurer. While that increase is manageable compared to some rural cases, it still underscores how widespread the crisis has become.
According to a July 2024 Placer County survey, more than half of local homeowners reported that their policies were either non-renewed or renewed at sharply higher costs. Similar resolutions calling for emergency action have now emerged in Shasta and San Bernardino Counties.
“It’s truly a crisis,” Gonzalez said — a sentiment echoed throughout the region.
Why Placer County Is Calling for a State Emergency
In September 2024, the Placer County Board of Supervisors unanimously adopted a resolution urging Governor Newsom, Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara, and the state Legislature to take immediate action.
Supervisor Bonnie Gore summarized the move simply: “We just felt it was time to make a strong statement.”
The county is requesting:
- Emergency regulatory steps to accelerate insurer rate approvals
- Reforms that recognize wildfire mitigation in pricing and renewal decisions
- State support for fire-safe communities that continue to face cancellations despite risk-reduction investments
Placer County leads the nation in “Firewise” certified communities — neighborhoods that complete extensive wildfire preparedness and defensible space programs. Yet many residents say those efforts rarely translate into insurance savings or renewal protection.
One survey respondent wrote, “Doing the defensible space work makes you feel better, but it doesn’t result in any savings or protection from cancellation.”
The Statewide Insurance Breakdown Behind the Emergency
What Placer County is experiencing reflects a broader statewide retreat that has been building for years. Major insurers including State Farm, Allstate, Farmers, and USAA have reduced or halted new homeowners policies across large parts of California.
Wildfire losses, construction inflation, and rigid rate regulations have made underwriting increasingly unprofitable. As private carriers withdraw, homeowners are pushed into the California FAIR Plan — a bare-bones, high-cost insurer of last resort.
With hundreds of thousands of policies now on the FAIR Plan, it has expanded far beyond its original design and faces mounting financial strain.
As Alex Bell noted, “That’s California’s bare-bones, high-cost insurer of last resort.” For many families, it is the only insurance option left.
What the State Has Done So Far
Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara has acknowledged the severity of the crisis. In 2023, he introduced the Sustainable Insurance Strategy to modernize the market while keeping Proposition 103 intact.
The strategy centers on three core reforms:
Accelerated rate approvals to reduce year-long regulatory delays that leave insurers pricing with outdated data.
Limited use of forward-looking catastrophe models so insurers can price wildfire risk accurately, but only if they agree to write more policies in high-risk areas.
Strengthened solvency protections for the FAIR Plan as its enrollment has surged from roughly 100,000 policies in 2019 to nearly 400,000 in 2024.
Together, these measures are designed to restore availability while maintaining consumer protections.
Why Timing Has Become the Central Problem
While most industry experts, including Insurance Hour host Karl Susman, agree these reforms are necessary, Placer County officials argue that the timeline is too slow.
“Waiting for a year or two for more admitted carriers to come in is too long for some people,” the county’s letter to Sacramento warned.
Residents losing coverage today cannot wait until 2025 for relief. Local officials say the insurance crisis is already suppressing home sales, complicating mortgages, and slowing economic development.
Without near-term solutions, they warn, rural and suburban communities could face long-term decline driven not by fire damage, but by uninsurable property.
How Regulation and Risk Fell Out of Balance
The core structural problem is the growing disconnect between real-world wildfire risk and California’s rate-setting system.
Insurers face:
- Rising wildfire losses
- Soaring construction and rebuilding costs
- Escalating reinsurance expenses
At the same time, Proposition 103 requires advance regulatory approval for rate increases — a process that can stretch well beyond a year and is often challenged through the intervener system.
When insurers cannot charge rates that reflect modern risk, many simply stop offering coverage altogether. The 2024 reforms attempt to fix this by allowing future-risk modeling with strict transparency requirements.
The Human Impact on Homeowners and Communities
In Placer County and other affected regions, the fallout is already deeply personal. Homeowners are:
- Paying double or triple for replacement coverage
- Relying on limited FAIR Plan policies
- Being forced to sell homes they can no longer insure
Because lenders require homeowners insurance, the crisis also threatens mortgage eligibility, refinancing opportunities, and overall housing stability.
For families who have lived in these communities for generations, the loss of affordable coverage feels like forced displacement driven not by fire itself, but by the inability to insure against it.
The Push to Reward Wildfire Mitigation Efforts
A major source of frustration for communities like Placer County is that wildfire mitigation often goes unrewarded.
Homeowners have invested heavily in:
- Defensible space
- Fire-resistant roofing
- Vegetation management
- Community preparedness programs
Yet most insurers still do not consistently factor those efforts into pricing or renewal decisions. Both county leaders and state regulators agree this must change.
Future regulations under Lara’s plan are expected to include formal incentives that allow mitigation work to translate into premium reductions and improved insurability.
“Housing-hardening investments need to be recognized by insurers,” one supervisor emphasized.
Statewide Response and the Promise of Market Reform
Despite local frustration, both the Governor’s office and the Department of Insurance maintain that large-scale relief is on the way.
In a statement to ABC10, the CDI said it will enact multiple regulations, administrative actions, and public meetings by the end of the year to expand insurer participation statewide. The Governor’s office confirmed that the state is overhauling the insurance system on an accelerated timeline.
Industry analysts widely expect that 2025 will mark the beginning of genuine market reopening — with more insurers returning, broader pricing tools, and reduced dependence on the FAIR Plan.
From Emergency Declaration to Market Evolution
Placer County’s emergency call is more than a local complaint — it is a statewide warning. The insurance crisis is no longer confined to high-mountain or deep-rural communities. It has moved into suburbs and once-stable neighborhoods.
The reforms now underway are ambitious and long overdue. But the central issue remains speed — closing the gap between policy reform and real relief for homeowners losing coverage today.
“We’re hopeful,” one supervisor said. “But hope doesn’t pay premiums.”
California’s insurance future now depends on striking a delicate balance: acting fast enough to stabilize the market in the short term, while building a system resilient enough to survive the next generation of wildfires.
If that balance is achieved, Placer County’s declaration may ultimately be remembered not as a moment of panic — but as the turning point that forced California to confront its insurance crisis head-on and rebuild from the brink.
Author
